- Fideres’s preliminary investigation into the US title insurance industry finds that title insurance premium levels are excessive – they overcompensate insurers for the level of risk assumed;
- While home insurance and car insurance companies pay upwards of 80% of their premium in claims, title insurers’ pay-outs are typically 3 to 4%;
- The McCarran Fergusson Act provides for the business of insurance to be regulated by state governments across the US. In around 40 states, title insurers are required to comply with a mandated minimum premium;
- However, Fideres found a lack of competition and inflated premium levels in seven states where premiums are unregulated, namely: Arkansas, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Oklahoma, and Virginia.
Title insurance protects homebuyers against disputes arising over ownership of property. Title insurers use records and public documents to verify that sellers are the legal property owners and collect a fee in exchange for an obligation to pay costs should a dispute arise. In 2017, the total amount of title insurance premiums paid in the US was approximately $15 billion.
There are two types of title insurance: the lender’s policy (which protects the lender up to the loan amount), and the owner’s policy (which protects the property buyer up to the property price). In most cases, the buyer pays for both policies.
Although it is possible for consumers to purchase title insurance directly on the open market, most homebuyers have title insurance selected for them by their real estate agents or mortgage brokers.
The transaction process may vary from state to state. The chart below provides an overview of the industry structure, its main players, and financial flows:
Title insurance is regulated at a state level, and the terms and conditions of regulations vary across states. For around forty states, regulations require charging a state mandated minimum premium. In certain states, for example, New Jersey, rates are proposed by trade organizations and implemented upon approval by local authorities. In more than seven states, however, rates remain unregulated.
The McCarran Fergusson Act is a federal law that exempts the business of insurance from most federal regulation, including federal antitrust actions to a large extent. Additionally, some federal appellate circuits also consider the “filed rate” doctrine as a successful defense to antitrust liability in title insurance cases. Keeping the above immunity challenges in mind, we focus our analysis on states where premiums are unregulated, and insurers could exploit their market position without intervention to set unreasonably high rates.
Plus factors are economic circumstances that facilitate collusion. While they do not directly imply collusion, the presence of plus factors allows the easier formation and maintenance of a cartel. Fideres has identified the following plus factors in the title insurance market:
High Market Shares and Concentration
The market is highly concentrated with the four largest firms accounting for 85% of new premiums written. Market HHI is 2,174 (defined as a moderately concentrated market in terms of the DOJ Horizontal Merger Guidelines).
High and Uniform Prices
Title insurance prices seem to be notoriously high and somewhat uniform in the observed sample of regulated and unregulated states. In many cases, agents representing multiple underwriters quote the same premium for all of them. For example, the same premium of $2,350 is quoted for a $500,000 home in Illinois by an agent representing five major underwriters.
Barriers to Entry
High access costs for title status databases (title plants) from incumbent title insurers, arrangements between insurers and real estate brokerage service providers, reverse competition in kickbacks, and title agent fees, present significant barriers for new market entrants.
Increasing vertical integration and acquisitions of title agents within the industry has resulted in fewer firms competing at all levels, facilitating price collusion.
Opportunities to Collude
Similar to the structure in regulated states where official authorities are responsible for publishing the coordinated rates, it is likely that title insurance companies in unregulated states use downstream channels such as title agency companies to coordinate their prices.
State-run vs. Private Title Insurance
Most of the developed world uses a land registration system called Torrens title, in which the state keeps a definitive record of land ownership and there is no need for title insurance as such. It is worth highlighting that Iowa, for example, has introduced a state-run title insurance system. Iowa Title Guaranty is the only entity authorized to do business in Iowa. Instead of having title insurance agents, Iowa certifies an abstractor to perform the records search, a private practice attorney then reviews it and issues an opinion – the abstract is then updated and loan completed. Iowa Guaranty passes on the charges to attorneys and abstractors, but no money goes back to the lender, eliminating the kickback problems. Any excess revenue beyond operating expenses is given to affordable housing initiatives in Iowa. The introduction of the Iowa state run scheme in 1987 has resulted in a reduction in premium costs:
Source: The American Title Insurance Industry
Consumers based in states where title insurance premiums are not subject to a mandated minimum level might have paid inflated prices as a result of anti-competitive conduct by incumbent title insurance.
Based on the sample of regulated states and corresponding rates chosen, some preliminary findings are:
- Unregulated states such as Illinois, Virginia, Georgia, and Massachusetts are among the top 15 states in terms of the amount of title insurance premiums written in 2016;
- We find that average title insurance rates charged in these unregulated states are considerably higher than in the sample of regulated states;
- Additionally, we find that the average title insurance rates paid as a proportion of the policy amount are also higher in the unregulated states, when compared to the regulated states;
- Some title agency companies in unregulated states such as Hawaii, Oklahoma, and Illinois advertise the same title insurance rates, even though they work with various underwriters.
Source: The System for Electronic Rates & Forms Filing
Alberto is a founding partners of Fideres, with over 21 years of cumulative industry experience.
His area of expertise is complex antitrust investigations and regulatory advisory work. He has handled some of Fideres’s largest and most complex economic investigations into the collusive practices of the financial industry, including ISDAfix and LIBOR benchmark manipulation, Generic Pharmaceuticals Cartel case and, more recently, abuse of dominance cases against monopolistic digital platforms. Before founding Fideres, he held senior managerial positions in New York and London at investment banks including UBS, ABN AMRO and The Royal Bank of Scotland. His investment banking expertise was in in fixed income bonds and derivatives markets, with a specialty in structured products.
Alberto holds master-level degrees in Engineering from Politecnico di Torino and from Ecole Centrale Paris.